New Theories!

So after the Big ReveAl tonight, I now have more ideas, thoughts, and theories just like everyone else. So here's what I am thinking now: 

We know that Mona was the first A and Charles took the game from her. Mona was just doing it to get back at Ali for treating her so bad. Charles is Jason's brother and Ali's half brother which means he is also Spencer's half brother.  He's super smart and also has some sort of mental disorder. I think he was taken to Radley because of that. I think he was always jealous of Ali for getting all the attention or something. I think he met Bethany in Radley and became friends with her maybe even more. I think he confided in Bethany told her everything. I think Mrs. D got a job at Radley to keep an eye on her son and make sure he was ok. I think that's how she knew about Bethany. I think Charles got Bethany to believe everything he said and got her to feel the same way he does and Mrs. D found out about it and wanted to keep her quiet and bribed her with gifts and trips. 

It could also be that Bethany and Charles are one in the same, I'm just not sure yet which it is. I still think it is Sara Harvey in Ali's grave. Why she was dressed like Ali that night I think that was to make people believe that Ali was dead I think the plan that night was to kill Ali but it didn't happen that way. Mrs. D knew Charles was jealous of Ali, she knew what would happen if Ali's dad found out about everything so she did everything she could to keep it all a secret from him. I think Mrs. D was afraid of her husband that's why she had affairs it got her away from him and she felt loved. 

I believe that Charles is who Mrs. D was protecting that night when she saw him hit Ali over the head with a rock. I think she knew that he and possibly Bethany too broke out of Radley that night when she got that phone call earlier and that's why she tried to get Ali to stay home she knew Charles was a danger to her. I think that Charles used Sara to look like Ali was dead in that grave and it was dark so nobody could tell the difference and I think Melissa burried her because she thought that Spencer had killed "Ali" who was really Sara Harvey. 

I think for a while Charles thought that Ali was really dead until he found out that she was alive. I think it was Charles and maybe Bethany too that were hiding out in Mrs D's basement. I feel like he killed his mom because she said she couldn't protect him anymore and that made him mad. It pushed him over the edge. I'm not quite sure why he killed the other's though. I'm not quite sure if Jason knew he had a brother or not. I feel like Spencer's dad knew of course and I feel like he was helping Mrs. D keep it a secret. 

I'm not quite sure why he is torturing all of the girls though, maybe because they are Ali's best friends and anyone connected to Ali in some way is fair game to him I just don't know yet. 

I knew Mona was alive! I knew she was too smart to be taken down. Charles (A) still double crossed her though but instead of killing her he turned her into his obsession, his sister Ali. He locked her in his creepy dollhouse in the middle of nowhere and made her play his twisted game as Ali and when the time was right, he put the real Ali in prison for Mona's murder which never even happened, made the other girls get arrested just to kidnap them and take them to his twisted dollhouse world, why I'm not quite sure yet but I'm working on it. 

I also feel like we have seen Charles before and I feel like he went by another name too not quite sure who yet though but I have my thoughts but will discuss that later. 

Anyway, I have 2 ways to look at my theories now, 1 Bethany and Charles are the same person, and 2 Bethany and Charles met in Radley and became friends or maybe more (bf/gf). 

Questions: What does creepy Andrew have to do with all of this? Who was/is Paul Varjak? What does Cyrus really have to do with everything? 

So I just saw that we will have all Big A answers by the end of 6 A this summer! Interesting!! 

Lastly, I TOLD YA'LL ARIA WASN'T A!!!! SHE WAS NEVER A!!!!! SHE COULD NEVER HURT ANYONE!!!!! TEAM ARIA FOR LIFE!!!!